Fagundo participated in both indoor and outdoor track and field as well as in volleyball during her time at Dover High School. In track and field, she earned her team's Coaches Award three times and was an NHIAA Scholar-Athlete all four years.
Born in St. Joseph, Mich., Fagundo is the youngest child of Jonathan and Tracey Fagundo. She has an older sister named Ashley. She is majoring in nuclear medicine. She also plays volleyball at Regis.